Christian Equivalent of the Taliban? A Somewhat Expanded Blast from the Past

I am not a Christian. I describe as an “Asatru leaning agnostic” or maybe “a practitioner, if not a believer, in Asatru”. (A friend of mind has coined the term “Agnostipagan” which I like.)

Still, I’d I have to say that Christians make far better neighbors than many another group. Yeah, they have their bad apples but the comparison between Christians as a group, at least in the Western world, and Isis or the Taliban is beyond ridiculous. Part of that is simply a matter of civilization. People simply behave better in the civilized world than they do in the more barbaric regions. However Christians in the civilized world try to spread civilization. Groups like Isis and the Taliban try to spread barbarism. Apples and dark matter they have so little in common.

Some people will point to groups like the Westboro Baptist Church and say that they are The equivalent of ISIS or the Taliban.  Excuse me?  people who stand around with signs saying mean things are the equivalent of those who cut off heads and burn people alive?  May I ask what you’re smoking so that I can make sure to stay well away from it?  Or another claim was a guy who videoed burning a copy of the Koran. “He’s just like the Taliban” some folk claimed.  And apparently they were serious.  Burning bound pieces of paper with ink on them on one hand, shooting girls in the face for trying to get an education or throwing acid on them for “immodesty.”  Gee, can’t see any difference whatsoever there.

That’s sarcasm, in case there’s any doubt.

When I point this out, some people try to respond by saying “they would if they could” (do all the horrid things we see from folk like Isis or the Taliban). First off, it’s ridiculously easy to claim what someone “would do”.  No connection to reality is even required, only one’s own prejudices.  But even if we stipulate that for sake of argument, the fact that they can’t while ISIS and the Taliban can (or could back before they got their butts kicked) is pretty telling.  A strong majority of Americans are some flavor of Christian.  The fact that anyone who might be so inclined to actually act like the Taliban or Isis, in the name of Christianity can’t without being slapped down hard by the rest is exactly what you expect when they’re a “tiny minority.”

I have yet to meet a Christian who believes I must die for being asatruar (well, leaning that way anyway). They may try to convince me of their belief. They may be concerned for my immortal soul. But they do not say I should be killed for not believing in “the god of the book.” How have ISIS and the Taliban weighed in on that? Is, perhaps, the choice they offer Islam, Dhimmitude (for Christians and Jews–“people of the book”), or death?

The Crusades you say? Well, leave aside that the Crusades were quite a few centuries ago, you might want to look more deeply into the history behind them. It was a lot more complicated than simply wanting to kill the infidel in the name of Christianity.

As for folk like the abortion clinic murderers and the like that are often paraded about as examples of how “Christians are just as bad”, you might want to consider the religious leanings of the people who investigated those crimes, the people who caught the culprits, the people who tried them, the people who convicted them, and the people who punished them. Simple statistics suggests that the majority of them were some flavor of Christian.  Christians policing their own, not giving their co-religionists a pass or making excuses for them simply because they apply the same name to the deity they believe in and agree on who brought said deity’s word to them.

The simple truth is, they are not the same.  So, would people stop with the false comparisons?

6 thoughts on “Christian Equivalent of the Taliban? A Somewhat Expanded Blast from the Past”

    1. Given they have been that violent in their, relatively short, history I am surprised people think The Book of Mormon is a good idea.

      The fact is, what they claim Christians would do is what a significant fraction of Moslems do. Yet, the criticize the Christians. They are teaching Christians and adjacent faiths the lesson that they are better off doing what they are accused of doing. Doing it not only quells the accusations but get the people currently making the accusations attacking the people who correctly point out people doing it.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. Regarding the “would do it if they could” argument, I find it somewhat amusing (for admittedly “bent” forms of amusement) that those making that claim about WBC (or Christians in general) are themselves more than happy to carry out abuses when they think they can get away with it (Antifa at Charlottesville in 2017, f’rex, when the cops not only refused to enforce laws prohibiting protesting in masks or assault, but arranged things so the “Unite the Right” people had to pass through an Antifa gauntlet to leave the area).

    In short: “Projection: It’s a helluva drug.”


  2. It might interest you to know that i could also be described as an Asatru-leaning agnostic.
    To be a bit more specific: i am agnostic on epistemological grounds; but when it comes to ethics, i tend to the worldview of the Sagas of Icelanders. (Hence my nom d’internet.)

    To get into more details — and here i get to the topic of this post — I believe that we should all have Asatru attitudes vis-a-vis people over whom we do not have unchecked power; but we should all be Christian, or at least Lockeans, to people over whom we have unchecked power.

    An implication is that, other things being equal, we should prefer to be ruled by people who believe that they are going to rot in Hell if they do not respect our Lockean rights.


  3. As a Biblical Christian (as much as possible ❤️) whose goal is to Save people from a horrible eternal death, the idea that I would kill somebody for not believing how I do is absurd. I look back on the skeletons in the closet of Church history and wonder if we read the same Bible.
    So I really appreciate this!!! So well said!! Those of us who try to kill people are the messed up outliers who are DIRECTLY disobeying God’s commands. The same canNOT be said for Islam.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: